This kind of nonsensical distortion and afactuality pervades the truth about blackfish. There are documented instances of killer whales attacking humans in the wild. All of the falsehoods and misleading techniques in blackfish are employed in the service of the films obvious bias, one that is best revealed near the end of blackfish by a neuroscientist with no. Harrowing and illuminating, blackfish tells the story of seaworlds tilikum, a 12,000pound bull orca, who caused the death of three humans, including his trainer, dawn brancheau, in 2010. Blackfish is a 20 american documentary film directed by gabriela cowperthwaite.
Months after blackfish release, controversy over seaworld grows an antiseaworld movement has unfolded online and on social media in the wake of. Seaworld does not, and has never, blamed trainer dawn brancheau for her death. Another deceptive claim on the website is one of its most prominent. This twopage worksheet is a comprehensive way to ensure that students are watching the blackfish documentary with purpose. The website in question is truth about blackfish, if anyone wants to find information on what seaworld has to say. Blackfish shows the sometimes devastating consequences of keeping such intelligent and sentient creatures in captivity. Thanks for writing this, all the lies that pro caps are spreading about this doc is. Even though the documentary blackfish is a couple years old, i recently found the time to watch it. Gabriela cowperthwaite explains why she was motivated as a mother to make the film blackfish, which airs on cnn thursday, october 24. Blackfish is the newest example of subgenre of documentaries that could be the 21st century animal rights version of abolitionist pamphlets. Notorious killer whale tilikum is responsible for the deaths of three individuals, including a top killer whale trainer. Old clips of seaworlds commercials show the public image of playful dolphins and orcas, celebrating mans. The results of the climate wars were that the majority of the earth was either flooded or burnt to rubble leaving very little in the way of habitual environments.
When it comes to the seaworld orca debate, americans need to remember the principles this country was founded on and let the facts speak for themselves. In blackfish, director gabriela cowperthwaite has given the world a very effective and compelling piece of filmmaking. After watching the documentary, heaps of people are now against seaworld and believe they mistreat their killer whales. Tilikums fame stems from a deadly attack on a trainer at orlando seaworld february 24th 2010. Blackfish is a documentary film, directed by gabriela cowperthwaite, that tells the story of tilikum. Its amazing that good people can be so easily misled by cheap lies and emotionally driven narrative. Through stock footage and video mismatched to the narrative, the film implies that seaworld collects killer whales from the wild and separates mothers and calves. The film blackfish tells the story of a young orca whale named tilikum who is stolen from his family in a shameless act of stratagem in 1983 and follows the 30year history of tilikums captivity and mistreatment at seaworld. Kleiman, joe dissecting blackfish page 3 about the author joe kleiman has been involved in sales, marketing, and management of filmbased attractions since 1997. Tilikum in blackfish 20 gabriela cowperthwaite at an event for blackfish 20 dave duffus in blackfish 20 blackfish 20. Blackfish tells the tragic story of a seaworld trainer killed by a 12,000 pound orca in 2010. Blackfish 20, a documentary that stands tall and still mangles heartstrings three years after its release, provides an in depth look into the miserable lives captive orcas live. All content included on our site, such as text, images, digital downloads and other, is the property of its content suppliers and protected by us and international laws.
Kittleson offers personal insight and experience as a trainer at seaworld, having worked with many of the orcas directly profiled in the film. A rhetorical evaluation of the documentary making waves. Sharkwater, about the organized butchery of sharks, the cove, about the mistreatment of dolphins, and gabriela cowperthwaites new film about orcas arent subtle, but they arent trying to be. Orca documentary lacks scope, but delivers strong message. It runs in 800x600x16 graphics mode, either windowed or full screen. Seaworld lies, false marketing of orcas must stop, new. Killer whales, seaworld, and the truth beyond blackfish by john hargrove in doc, epub, fb2 download ebook. The safest inference would be these are animals that have highly elaborated emotional lives. Since i first started reporting on tilikum, seaworld and orcas in captivity, there have been efforts to delegitimize. There is no scientific evidence to support this claim, however, there is scientific evidence that says that 14 of adult male southern resident sorcas have bent or collapsed dorsal fins. Over the course of tracking his history, blackfish. Willie nelson is just one of the artists rushing to cancel gigs at seaworld after seeing blackfish, the oscarnominated. Cowperthwaite asked for interviewers to be sent to seaworld to question them. While i was not able to catch this documentary in the theaters during its limited release last summer, i was able to catch it on cnn earlier this week and, as a lawyer, i am compelled to admit to some appreciation for the work that was done.
It was an astounding 32 pages of misleading information that even broke it down to the second of the 1. Former seaworld killer whale trainer says blackfish is a lie. Blackfish, a documentary by gabriela cowperthwaite, makes the claim that killer whales should be freed from their captive enclosures in entertainment facilities due to the danger they pose towards humans and themselves. Walking away from blackfish, many in the audience are left with the impression that orcas in the wild live to be a hundred years old, while seaworlds orcas live only 25. Starting with the death of orca trainer dawn brancheau, blackfish tells the history. Blackfish, seaworld and the backlash against killer whale theme park shows. The film begins with haunting music and a dark screen while various calls to the police are being made about a trainer being eaten by one of the killer whales at seaworld orlando. New seaworld ads take on lies about its killer whale shows. Weve got a string of organizations success stories a walking mile long to show for it. Featuring testimonies from experts and trainers, and with neverbeforeseen footage, blackfish artfully and. Blackfish states that after kasatka and katina were separated from their babies, they were making these calls that no one had ever heard before. The issue of orca life expectancy features prominently in blackfish and it is an issue that has really stuck with people after watching the film. The truth about the truth about blackfish the dodo. Seaworld lies, false marketing of orcas must stop, new suit says.
I am not a big save the whales person, but this film gave me a totally different way of looking at sea world and animals in captivity. Blackfish says that less than 1% of killer whales in the wild have collapsed dorsal fins. Former killer whale trainer says blackfish is a lie. Scheffer 1969 reports a killer whale marked with regular lines suggesting. Blackfish print and go worksheet for analysis of the. I read through a pdf file that they uploaded for audience benefits that breaks down every single thing that blackfish claimed.
When you dont like the message, and the facts are not on your side, distract and confuse the debate by attacking the messengers. Truth is in the facts an open letter from the informed american public pdf. The documentary explores seaworlds treatment of killer whales and interviews past and present employees and orca trainers. I have never described any animal ive made a relationship with as sad, or angry. News release from earth island institute on april lawsuit pdf.
However, blackfish has lots of inaccuracies and in the film that confuses people or makes them misunderstand things. The truth about the truth about blackfish crooks and liars. Recently i came across a documentary called blackfish. Seaworld killer whale trainer responds to blackfish. The story of a killer whale who has taken the lives of several people while in captivity. Former seaworld senior killer whale trainer, kyle kittleson, has published a video and article in response to the controversial documentary, blackfish. However, cowperthwaite discovered it wasnt just this particular whalethere have been multiple cases of orca attacks on trainers in parks around the world, although never in the wild. It tells the story of tilikum, an orca held by seaworld and the controversy over captive killer whales and other animals. In the film, there was a team of whale hunters who hunted tilikum and his family by herding the female whales and their babies using a large sane net and by throwing bombs. To many whove seen it, blackfish is a damning indictment of seaworld and its decision to hold killer whales captive. There are many examples of crafted activism in psuedodocumentaries. Blackfish tells the story of tilikum, a performing killer whale that killed several people while in captivity.
The park has not collected an orca from the wild in over 35 years. Wanting to kind of preserve the tape i actually used the editing equipment and like snipped out. Associate producer and cowriter of the documentary blackfish. When identifying the message, approach and purpose of blackfish. Araceli govea professor lorie hamalian english 115 30 october 2014 blackfish gabriela cowperthwaites documentary blackfish explores the harm captivity causes to whales and their trainers. Since 1999, kleiman has been a freelance writer contributing to a number of. An earlier version of this article identified the pbs affiliate. But seaworld and some of its former killer whale trainers say the documentary offers a misleading portrayal of the marine parks practices to help you get up to speed, i dove into some of the movies key claims and asked seaworld to respond. Addressing some criticism of blackfish the earthist. This film is a perfect example of how these rhetorical components are used to create an effective argument.
The same can be said of the several former seaworld trainers who appeared in the film, describing the companys dubious practices. First of all, in the footage you see the killer whales opening their mouth and you hear killer whale calls. The lies the following are all falses and innacuracies that i and other people have noted while and after watching the film. A mesmerising psychological thriller with a killer whale at its centre, blackfish is the first film since grizzly man to show how nature can get revenge on man when pushed to its limits. This is quite the contrary approach to super size me, where spurlock often ate as much as 5,000 supercalories in a day. Blackfish does a fantastic job of evoking emotions in all of its viewers.
Seaworld unleashes 8 assertions about blackfish and filmmakers. The simple fact is that most of the claims in blackfish are blatant lies. The whales are never withheld food, never forced to do anything, and have incredible relationships with their trainers. They were presented with the truth about orca care, they just chose not to use it. But even better, theres more good going out into the world every day because of what we do. Firstly, the film shows how the killer whales end up at sealand.
The documentary blackfish is very bias considering it mostly shows the negative effect that sealand and seaworld has had on killer whales, especially tilikum. Just a small percentage of blackfish is actually accurate. Beyond the lies, beneath the deception, the truth will surface. The iconic super size me is a premiere example of this covered in skeptoid episode 88. This research focuses on the crisis that the documentary blackfish precipitated at seaworld. All the hard work seaworld does for all ocean life is being destroyed by peta with the blatant lies of blackfish. Time stamp description misleading andor inaccurate. Throughout the film the orca whales undergo a transformation from defenseless creatures into molded killers. Heres how the truth about blackfish concludes, describing marinos assessments. Blackfish has the credentials, and weve nailed the process. In 2010, a trainer who worked for sea world, dawn brancheau was killed by one of the show whales in sea world tilikum which set off this controversy and the realization that orcas should not be.
915 778 140 1542 1516 625 854 137 325 378 1355 692 649 1417 1047 1090 79 1238 1176 1127 1373 1258 503 1434 569 280 230 1308 1464 219 680 62 323 872 1366 437 69 1422 1392 1154 1215 1455 1035 998 243 1024