Abusive supervision refers to sustained displays of nonphysical forms of hostility perpetrated by supervisors against their direct reports. Specifically, we hypothesized that individuals with lower levels of social adaptability. Employees from diverse organizations in malaysia n 140 were. Workplace mistreatment is comprised of a multitude of behaviors such as violence, aggression, bullying, incivility, and abusive supervision, and it poses a serious problem to. Therefore, it is meaningful to explore the effects of abusive supervision on task performance. Effects of abusive supervision and coworker support on. The interactive effects of abusive supervision and.
Drawing on justice theory, i examined the consequences of abusive supervisor behav ior. A recent naveen jindal school of management study examined the damaging impact abusive supervision has in the workplace including the ways employees respond with retaliatory behavior, which lowers. Abusive supervision impacts employees wellbeing and work. Abusive supervision, upward maintenance communication. Researchers find that employees who report abusive supervision tend to retaliate against supervisors e. The interactive effects of abusive supervision and entitlement on emotional exhaustion and co. Drawing on social learning theory and social information. Consequences of abusive supervision compared with nonabused subordinates, abused subordinates have higher quit rates, and among those who stay in the job, abusive supervision is negatively related to subordinates job satisfaction, commitment to the organization, and trust in the supervisor, and. Effects of super visors abusive actions include important areas, such as job satisfaction and organizational commitment aryee et al. Organizational justice mediated most of these effects, and job mobility moderated some of the deleterious effects of abusive supervision. A multiplemediation model of its impact on group outcomes abstract in this paper we introduce the construct of abusive supervision climate, the collective perceptions employees hold regarding abusive supervision in their work unit. Abusive supervision refers to subo rdinates perceptions of the extent to which supervisors engage in the sustained.
Psychologically entitled employees who perceive more abusive supervision are more emotionally exhausted and more likely to abuse their co. Abusive supervision and workplace deviance and the moderating. The effects of perceived organizational support, abusive. That of abusive supervision is a subjective evaluation made by the subordinate about the leadership style of hisher boss, and so the same behavior can be abusive for someone but not for someone else. Abusive supervision oxford research encyclopedia of. As expected, subordinates who perceived their supervisors. However, the effects of supervisory styles coaching, mentoring and abusive supervision on talent development and the moderating effects of clinical learning environment in the relationship between supervisory styles and talent development among public hospital trainee doctors have not been thoroughly researched. Introduction over the past decade, recent attention has been given to understand the causes and consequences of abusive supervision. However, researchers have used different terminology to explore phenomena that overlap with abusive supervision, and extant research does not devolve from a unifying theoretical framework. Drawing on justice theory, the author examined the consequences of abusive supervisor behavior. Abusive supervisors impact victims and coworkers alike bosses abusive behavior toward subordinates not only has a detrimental effect on victims, but their behavior also has a similar negative impact on the victims coworkers, who experience secondhand, or vicarious, abusive supervision.
Results showed that abusive supervision had an indirect negative relationship with employee creativity via its impact on employee sleep deprivation and emotional exhaustion. Further, previous research has not considered the effects of abusive supervision emanating from the top of the organizational hierarchy and has not evaluated the effects of abusive supervision on targets who themselves occupy leadership roles within their companies. The effect of abusive supervision on employee creativity in teams leaders have traditionally been conceptualized as an important contextual factor that cultivates or stifles employee creativity george, 2008. In the third section, we turn our attention to the growing body of research that explores the antecedent conditions and processes that explain when abusive supervision is. The consequences of abusive supervision io at work. As expected, subordinates who perceived their supervisors were. Dec 11, 2018 findings from two multisource, multiwave studies of supervisorsubordinate dyads provide support for the theses that 1 downward envy of subordinates threatens supervisors selfesteem and triggers adaptive strategies in the form of abusive supervision and supervisory selfimprovement. For subordinates who remained with their jobs, abusive supervision was associated with lower job and life satisfaction, lower normative and affective commitment, and higher continuance. Abusive supervision and workplace deviance and the moderating effects of negative reciprocity beliefs marie s.
Pdf subordinate social adaptability and the consequences. Pdf abusive supervision and negative employee outcomes. Using data from a large multisource field study, we extend this research by testing a trickledown model of abusive supervision across three hierarchical levels i. The effects of abusive supervision, emotional exhaustion, and perceived coworker support on subordinates intention to quit. Physical consequences range from minor injuries to severe brain damage and even death. Duffy university of kentucky the relationship between subordinates perceptions of abusive supervision and supervisors evaluations. Abusive supervisors impact victims and coworkers alike.
For over 30 years, clinicians have described the effects of child abuse and neglect on the physical, psychological, cognitive, and behavioral development of children. Abusive supervision variability was proposed to negatively affect a number of employee attitudes and behaviors through the mediating effects of interpersonal justice climate strength. In addition to individuallevel consequences, the consequences of abusive supervision can directly or indirectly impact the organizations bottom line. To date, however, insufficient attention has been paid to the impact of abusive supervision on employees task performance. Consequences of abusive supervision academy of management. On the causes and consequences of abusive supervision. Consequences of abusive supervision article pdf available in the academy of management journal 432. Child abuse has for a long time been recorded in literature, art and science in many parts of the. Abusive supervision has no direct physical consequences but in long terms it leaves negative impact 21. Consequences of abusive supervision have not been studied among migrant workers whose status in the host country of work is dependent on maintaining the work contract. A growing literature explores abusive supervision, nonphysical forms of hostility perpetrated by managers against their direct reports. Continue reading to learn about the effects of emotional abuse and how to get help.
Consistent with ployhart and blieses 2006 conceptualization, we integrate both resource and selfregulation perspectives to explain the consequences of abusive supervision as a function of variations in subordinates social. This study examined the direct and interactive effects of abusive supervision and coworker support on work engagement. Abusive supervision has been investigated as an antecedent to negative subordinate workplace outcome. Although abusive supervision is a low baserate phenomenon, its effects are noteworthy. Ambrose university of central florida in this study, the authors examine the relationship between abusive supervision and employee workplace deviance. Given its prevalence, researchers have sought to understand the consequences of abusive supervision and found it has a significant toll on its victims. For subordinates who remained with their jobs, abusive supervision was associated with lower job and life satisfaction, lower normative and affective commitment, and higher continuance commitment. Impact of abusive supervision on workplace deviance. Effects of abusive supervision and coworker support on work engagement june m. Tepper university of north carolina at charlotte michelle k.
Positioning abusive leadership as the focal variable, the antecedents and consequences of this construct are examined from both perspectives. The current study seeks to examine the link between abusive supervision and subordinate family undermining by focusing on the mediating role of work. View enhanced pdf access article on wiley online library html view download pdf for offline viewing. Abusive supervision and subordinates organizational citizenship behavior kelly l. Nagy and ronald paul hill villanova school of business abstract abuse may characterize some most important relationships, and it. In this dissertation, across two essays, i examine both the causes and the consequences of abusive supervision. Based on a metaanalysis of 119 independent samples n 35,239.
The study finds that abusive supervision motivates two types of behavior. Abusive supervision has been defined by tepper 2000 as. Abusive supervision, employee creativity, creative selfefficacy, power distance 1. Understanding the role of creative selfefficacy and power. The implications of the results for understanding destructive behaviors in the workplace are examined. A seminal article by tepper 2000 initiated a large body of research on the topic of abusive supervision. Abusive supervision is detrimental to the workplace. A small but growing body of empirical research suggests that abused subordinates report greater job and life dissatisfaction, intentions to quit their jobs, role conflict, and psychological distress, compared with their non. Regarding the consequences of abusive supervision, in essay 2, i drew upon a justice explanation of abusive supervision tepper, 2000 to explain under what circumstances and why the link between abusive supervision to subordinate wellbeing can be mitigated. Causes and consequences of abusive supervision in sales management. These findings contribute to a better understanding of the negative effects of abusive supervision on employee creativity and the processes by which they occur. Drawing on social learning theory and social information processing theory, we find general support for the study hypotheses.
Effective talent development requires robust supervision. In the following sections, i identify the constructs behavioral domain and invoke the organizational justice literature to explain the effects of abusive supervision on a variety of outcome variables. Abusive supervision is a growing problem confronting organizations. The neutralizing effects of ingratiation and positive affect on negative employee outcomes paul harveya. An examination of current research and a proposal for preventive measures. The effects of abusive supervision and social support on workplace aggression kimberly d. Researchers at the naveen jindal school of management at the. According to social learning theory bandura, 1977, 1986, individuals acquire social behavior. Antecedents of abusive supervision comparatively little research has explored the antecedents of abusive supervision. Abusive supervision and workplace deviance and the.
Abusive supervision in the workplace has a damaging impact on not only the employees, but also the business, according to a new study. First, by linking abusive supervision to actors state sense of power, managerial selfefficacy, and taskoriented leadership behavior, our findings enrich the understanding of the consequences of abusive supervision on actors i. Pdf drawing on justice theory, i examined the consequences of abusive supervisor behavior. An examination of current research and a proposal for preventive measures workplace mistreatment is comprised of a multitude of behaviors such as violence, aggression, bullying, incivility, and abusive supervision, and it poses a serious problem to organizations. Examples of behavior that fall within the abusive supervision content domain include public derogation, undermining, and explosive outbursts. Abusive supervision, upward maintenance communication, and. For subordinates who remained with their jobs, abusive supervision was associated with lower job and life satisfaction. As expected, subordinates who perceived their supervisors were more abusive were more likely to quit their jobs. We move beyond traditional static approaches to studying the antecedents of abusive supervision by proposing that daily abusive supervisor behavior varies in part on the quantity and quality of sleep the night before. Participants included 209 employees from a manufacturing company in china. In this study, the researcher has focused the study to examine the effects of abusive supervision on. Given this statistic, there is a clear need to investigate this topic within the marketing literature. Chapter 3 child abuse and neglect by parents and other. In the third section, we turn our attention to the growing body of research that explores the antecedent conditions and processes that explain when abusive supervision is more or less likely to occur.
The present study examined the consequences of a dispersion. Pdf subordinate social adaptability and the consequences of. As abusive supervision was the most often used concept in the studies we found, we compared the correlations between studies using the instrument assessing abusive supervision introduced by tepper 2000 and outcomes, on the one hand, and studies using a different instrument to assess destructive leadership e. For subordinates who remained with their jobs, abusive supervision was associated with lower job and life satisfaction, lower normative and affective. The mediating role of emotional exhaustion and the moderating role of work unit structure volume 4 issue 3 samuel aryee, liyun sun, zhen xiong george chen, yaw a. Abusive supervision and subordinates organizational. A recent naveen jindal school of management study examined the damaging impact abusive supervision has in the workplace including the ways employees. In the first section, we discuss research trends and provide clarification regarding the pressing and notsopressing problems with the way that abusive supervision is. The authors conceptualize abusive supervision as a type of. Recently, scholars have attempted to integrate largely disconnected elements of the adaptability literature.
Building on prior work showing that abusive supervision is a. In the present work, i sought to examine the causes and consequences of abusive supervision. As a result, the purpose of this study is to explore antecedents and outcomes of abusive supervision in sales management, where the performance. Although extant literature has not examined the effect of abusive supervision on creativity, a limited but. Causes and consequences of abusive supervision in sales. Abusive supervision for this study, abusive supervision refers to sub. The mediating effects of hindrance stress, anger, and anxiety mary b. While research has previously confirmed that abusive supervision can deplete an employees sense of self andas a resultlead to acts of deviance in the workplace, there is no integrated approach to the behavioral outcomes of abusive supervision. Subordinate social adaptability and the consequences of. Abusive supervision is most commonly studied in the context of the workplace, although it can arise in other areas such as in the household and at school. Abusive supervision and subordinates organizational citizenship. A small but growing body of empirical research suggests that abused subordinates report greater job and life dissatisfaction, intentions to quit their jobs, role conflict, and. Thus, in the case of abusive supervision, stronger negative reciprocity beliefs should be associated with increased deviant behavior directed at the supervisor. This section examines the impact of abuse and neglect on child development, as well as longterm consequences for adults with a history of abuse.
In essay 1, i answer the question when and why do supervisors abuse poor performing employees. Using data from a large multisource field study, we extend this research by testing a trickle. While a plethora of studies have examined the relationships between abusive supervision and outcomes, there is a lack of a comprehensive and systematic framework that integrates the consequences and moderators of abusive supervision. Abusive supervision and negative employee outcomes. The trickledown effect of abusive supervision in addition to explaining why behavioral constructs emerge at the group level, social learning theory can be used as theoretical support for our trickledown model of abusive supervision. Compared with nonabused subordinates, abused sub ordinates have higher quit rates, and. In the second section, we highlight problems and prospects in research on the consequences of abusive supervision. Sep 15, 2016 abusive supervision in the workplace has been shown to have important direct consequence in work and work relationship, and also indirect consequences to workers wellbeing and relationships outside work. The motivational effects of diminished self esteem for. Sep 28, 2015 while a plethora of studies have examined the relationships between abusive supervision and outcomes, there is a lack of a comprehensive and systematic framework that integrates the consequences and moderators of abusive supervision. When it comes to abusive supervision, an image of autocratic boss comes to mind who humiliate those who report to them 5 previous researches evident that abusive supervision is the first stone of deviance in organizations 5 and. The consequences of maltreatment can be devastating. First, in order to reassert control and protect their selfimage, employees of abusive supervisors will act out in selfdefense.
Abusive supervision in the workplace pdxscholar portland state. The effects of abusive supervision and social support on. A related question is which mechanism provides a stronger explanation for the negative effects of abusive supervision on employee ocb and cwb. Nov 30, 2017 drawing on justice theory, the author examined the consequences of abusive supervisor behavior. Results of two field studies and a daily diary study support the hypothesized model and show that abusive. Abusive supervision is defined as subordinates perceptions of the extent to which supervisors engage in the sustained display of hostile verbal and nonverbal behaviors, excluding physical contact p. Why abusive supervision impacts employee ocb and cwb. Latham3 1department of management, lebow college of business, drexel university, philadelphia, pennsylvania, u. The present investigation examined social adaptability as a moderator of the relationships between perceptions of abusive supervision and several work outcomes. Key features of the construct are that abusive supervision refers to ongoing manifestations of hostility rather. Pdf consequences of abusive supervision researchgate.
29 102 1367 919 945 907 990 1123 869 841 223 373 205 673 433 103 260 781 712 671 1387 238 1233 1063 1204 559 932 795 1488 1460 490 1357 751